Browning, C. (1997). Lymphoedema: Prevalence, risk factors and management: A review of research. Kings Cross, Australia: NHMRC National Breast Cancer Center.

Search Strategy

DATABASES USED: Detailed review of evidence undertaken using a MEDLINE search from 1985–1996. Additional references were retrieved from a survey of references in each article and from unpublished and in-press research from key researchers in the area.

INCLUSION CRITERIA: English language; sample size of 20 or more participants; lymphedema related to breast cancer treatment; if other patients were included, at least 20 participants needed to be patients with breast cancer, and data for these patients were reported separately

EXCLUSION CRITERIA: Animal studies and non-English articles were excluded. Articles were excluded if their data were already published, if they were lymphedema-physiology based, if they discussed measurement techniques only, or if they were review articles.

Sample Characteristics

  • FINAL NUMBER STUDIES INCLUDED = 41 
  • KEY SAMPLE CHARACTERISTICS: Treatments evaluated risk factor identification, lymphedema prevalence data, and treatment. No review of infection prevention or treatment is discussed in this document.

Results

Recommended for Practice
  • Complex physical therapy (also known as complete decongestive therapy) includes four components used together:
  • Skin care 
  • Manual lymphatic drainage (MLD)
  • Compression bandages
  • Exercise.

In this review, all studies reported significant improvement. There was no comparison or control group.

  • Compression techniques: Elastic sleeves (limitations in study quality)
 
Effectiveness not Established
  • Surgical techniques 
  • Microsurgical lymphatic venous anastomosis
  • Lymphatic grafting

Studies were limited by the lack of a control group, and careful patient selection appears key. Not all women benefited, and risks of surgery were not reported.

Not Recommended for Practice

  • Drug therapy
  • Oral benzopyrones (e.g.,coumarin): Small RCTs; drugs pose significant liver toxicity
Expert Opinion
  • Avoiding injury and heavy lifting, keeping weight under control, and avoiding injection, vaccination, and BP in affected arm seems prudent. 
  • Air flight, injury, and trauma often are identified as precipitating factors but are not well studied. Further research and inquiry are necessary. 
  • Caution against unsubstantiated recommendations citing a small study of women with lymphedema who needed hand surgery and successfully underwent surgery without any worsening of pre-existing lymphedema or onset of new swelling or infection.
  • Provide patient education regarding risk factors and life-style.
Risk Factors
  • Age: Three out of four studies reviewed suggested that older patients are more likely to develop lymphedema.
  • Wound complications and increased wound drainage
  • Obesity 
  • Prior infection
  • Axillary surgery
  • Radiotherapy
  • Recurrent disease

Nursing Implications

  • Strategies for early detection needed 
  • Lymphedema research needed

Legacy ID

4648